wip: resolution 047

2026-09-30 11:48:46 -03:00
1 changed files with 40 additions and 0 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,40 @@
 ---
 title: "Resolution 047: Moratorium on LLM use and discussion"
 ---
 - Topic: Moratorium on LLM use and discussion
 - Date: TBD
 - Deadline: 2 weeks after voting starts
 - Size: medium
 ### History
 Discussion about LLM use or ban have been appearing on the Federation's
 Matrix rooms.  Also git.coopcloud.tech has been receiving LLM-assisted
 pull requests on recipes.
 Members' and contributors' stances around LLM use are split, and there
 are valid fears of having a split because of it.
 Federation members 3wc, ammar and maren have been following these
 threads and preparing a process to allow us to reach a consensus around
 an AI policy for the Coopcloud Federation.
 The process has been proposed and collective steps towards following it
 are taking place. Any discussion outside this process only contributes
 to draining folks' energy.
 ### Proposal
 Self-impose a moratorium on LLM discussion on Federation's Matrix rooms
 and Git issues, to direct energies towards the process of establishing
 a consensus and an AI policy.
 LLM-assisted pull requests on more complex tools like `abra` are also
 within the moratorium, and will be put on hold until the AI policy is
 stablished.
 As for LLM-assisted pull requests, they should be clearly marked as
 such, and within each recipe maintainers' purview to accept or reject
 them.  This is because recipes with maintainers already have human
 review before merging.