Failed update silently rolls back #478

New Issue

Closed

opened 2025-01-08 18:17:27 +00:00 by 3wordchant · 7 comments

3wordchant commented 2025-01-08 18:17:27 +00:00

Owner

Copy Link

Copy Source

Steps to reproduce:

1. Deploy Gitea 3.0.1+1.22.3-rootless using an old version of abra that doesn't interact with versions in the .env file
2. abra app upgrade git.foo.bar

Expected result:

App upgraded

Actual result:

The correct new version is written to the .env file:

@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
-TYPE=gitea
+TYPE=gitea:3.0.2+1.22.6-rootless

But the old version is still deployed 🤔

Steps to reproduce: 1. Deploy Gitea `3.0.1+1.22.3-rootless` using an old version of abra that doesn't interact with versions in the `.env` file 2. `abra app upgrade git.foo.bar` Expected result: App upgraded Actual result: The correct new version is written to the `.env` file: ``` @@ -1,4 +1,4 @@ -TYPE=gitea +TYPE=gitea:3.0.2+1.22.6-rootless ``` But the old version is still deployed 🤔

3wordchant added the bug label 2025-01-08 18:17:27 +00:00

decentral1se commented 2025-01-08 21:43:55 +00:00

Owner

Copy Link

Copy Source

Hmmmm, it would seem that there is some confusion between a missing .env version and the parsing of the live deployment labels? A wild new edge case, great find! I will try to reproduce shortly.

Hmmmm, it would seem that there is some confusion between a missing `.env` version and the parsing of the live deployment labels? A wild new edge case, great find! I will try to reproduce shortly.

decentral1se added the release-candidate label 2025-01-08 21:44:03 +00:00

decentral1se commented 2025-01-09 09:55:03 +00:00

Owner

Copy Link

Copy Source

@3wordchant had a play with this. I found a bonus side bug which I'm gonna try fix up: #479

However, for the Gitea release latest release, I think it's failing to come up some time after depoloyment? Can you check that? I suspect the runtime is then rolling back to 3.0.1+1.22.3-rootless based on the deploy config and abra can't really do much since the deployment technically succeeded aka "silently rolling back because StAbiLiTy".

I could be wrong but I wasn't able to reproduce this with several integration tests. But I also wasn't able to get a succesful Gitea upgrade from 3.0.1.x to 3.0.2.x 🤔 I was seeing this error: https://github.com/go-gitea/gitea/issues/28388 (the "solution" is a bit of a mystery for me)

In the case I'm right, I'm not sure what we can do to make this obvious to people. Currently, you can docker ps -f name=<stack> -a to see exited containers? Are there better ways? How can this be incorporated into the abra output?

@3wordchant had a play with this. I found a bonus side bug which I'm gonna try fix up: https://git.coopcloud.tech/toolshed/abra/pulls/479 However, for the Gitea release latest release, I think it's failing to come up some time after depoloyment? Can you check that? I suspect the runtime is then rolling back to `3.0.1+1.22.3-rootless` based on the deploy config and `abra` can't really do much since the deployment technically succeeded aka "silently rolling back because StAbiLiTy". I could be wrong but I wasn't able to reproduce this with several integration tests. But I also wasn't able to get a succesful Gitea upgrade from `3.0.1.x` to `3.0.2.x` 🤔 I was seeing this error: https://github.com/go-gitea/gitea/issues/28388 (the "solution" is a bit of a mystery for me) In the case I'm right, I'm not sure what we can do to make this obvious to people. Currently, you can `docker ps -f name=<stack> -a` to see exited containers? Are there better ways? How can this be incorporated into the `abra` output?

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-01-09 10:36:29 +00:00

fix: dont set chaos label if no chaos

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-01-09 10:36:29 +00:00

fix: show N/A if env version unknown

decentral1se referenced this issue 2025-01-09 10:37:54 +00:00

fix: don't always set chaos label, missing .env version N/A handling #479

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-01-09 10:54:49 +00:00

fix: dont set chaos label if no chaos

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-01-09 10:54:49 +00:00

fix: show N/A if env version unknown

decentral1se referenced this issue 2025-01-09 11:11:12 +00:00

If a deploy fails, log output to file for inspection #473

decentral1se commented 2025-01-09 21:47:16 +00:00

Owner

Copy Link

Copy Source

Related: toolshed/organising#615

Related: https://git.coopcloud.tech/toolshed/organising/issues/615

decentral1se referenced this issue from toolshed/organising 2025-01-09 21:48:02 +00:00

`abra app upgrade` reports success even if app is still running old version of one service #615

decentral1se added question and removed bugrelease-candidate labels 2025-01-10 18:11:32 +00:00

decentral1se commented 2025-01-11 11:02:48 +00:00

Owner

Copy Link

Copy Source

Holy shit, I've just realised that we've been throwing away the output of the runtime deployment status all this time 😱 What the absolute hell 😂

With this diff:

diff --git a/pkg/upstream/stack/stack.go b/pkg/upstream/stack/stack.go
index 179c9090..18cfb222 100644
--- a/pkg/upstream/stack/stack.go
+++ b/pkg/upstream/stack/stack.go
@@ -4,7 +4,6 @@ import (
        "context"
        "fmt"
        "io"
-       "io/ioutil"
        "os"
        "os/signal"
        "strconv"
@@ -515,7 +514,7 @@ func WaitOnService(ctx context.Context, cl *dockerClient.Client, serviceID, appN
                errChan <- progress.ServiceProgress(ctx, cl, serviceID, pipeWriter)
        }()

-       go io.Copy(ioutil.Discard, pipeReader)
+       go io.Copy(os.Stdout, pipeReader)

        timeout := time.Duration(WaitTimeout) * time.Second

I get:

Chaotic log output

{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":" ","progressDetail":{},"id":"1/1"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e                 ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e      ] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"running  ","progressDetail":{"current":9,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[==================================================\u003e] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"1 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"Waiting 5 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"update rolled back due to failure or early termination of task 53lguaoid5yzmoeqxj4gavm31","progressDetail":{},"id":"rollback"}
{"status":"Waiting 5 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 5 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 4 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 4 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 4 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 3 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 3 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 2 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 2 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 2 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 1 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 1 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Service uk5o7v1uknioo8n0q2t61tdqp converged","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":" ","progressDetail":{},"id":"1/1"}
{"status":"running  ","progressDetail":{"current":9,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[==================================================\u003e] ","id":"1/1"}
{"status":"1 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"}
{"status":"Waiting 5 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 5 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 5 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 4 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 4 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 4 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 3 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 3 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 3 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 2 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 2 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 1 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 1 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Waiting 1 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}
{"status":"Service 77415ylhm56qt7rjypb03lp8i converged","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"}

Where we can clearly see:

update rolled back due to failure or early termination of task 53lguaoid5yzmoeqxj4gavm31

So, it's now just a question of how to show this. I might try to copy/pasta over the presentation logic of Docker itself. But that wouldn't help with #473. I might try some fancy layout 🤔

Tips welcome!

Holy shit, I've just realised that we've been throwing away the output of the runtime deployment status all this time 😱 What the absolute hell 😂 With this diff: ```diff diff --git a/pkg/upstream/stack/stack.go b/pkg/upstream/stack/stack.go index 179c9090..18cfb222 100644 --- a/pkg/upstream/stack/stack.go +++ b/pkg/upstream/stack/stack.go @@ -4,7 +4,6 @@ import ( "context" "fmt" "io" - "io/ioutil" "os" "os/signal" "strconv" @@ -515,7 +514,7 @@ func WaitOnService(ctx context.Context, cl *dockerClient.Client, serviceID, appN errChan <- progress.ServiceProgress(ctx, cl, serviceID, pipeWriter) }() - go io.Copy(ioutil.Discard, pipeReader) + go io.Copy(os.Stdout, pipeReader) timeout := time.Duration(WaitTimeout) * time.Second ``` I get: <details> <summary>Chaotic log output</summary> ``` {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":" ","progressDetail":{},"id":"1/1"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"preparing","progressDetail":{"current":6,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[=================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"starting ","progressDetail":{"current":8,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[============================================\u003e ] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"running ","progressDetail":{"current":9,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[==================================================\u003e] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"1 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"Waiting 5 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"update rolled back due to failure or early termination of task 53lguaoid5yzmoeqxj4gavm31","progressDetail":{},"id":"rollback"} {"status":"Waiting 5 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 5 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 4 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 4 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 4 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 3 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 3 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 2 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 2 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 2 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 1 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 1 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Service uk5o7v1uknioo8n0q2t61tdqp converged","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"0 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":" ","progressDetail":{},"id":"1/1"} {"status":"running ","progressDetail":{"current":9,"total":9,"hidecounts":true},"progress":"[==================================================\u003e] ","id":"1/1"} {"status":"1 out of 1 tasks","progressDetail":{},"id":"overall progress"} {"status":"Waiting 5 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 5 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 5 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 4 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 4 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 4 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 3 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 3 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 3 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 2 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 2 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 1 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 1 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Waiting 1 seconds to verify that tasks are stable...","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} {"status":"Service 77415ylhm56qt7rjypb03lp8i converged","progressDetail":{},"id":"verify"} ``` </details> Where we can clearly see: > update rolled back due to failure or early termination of task 53lguaoid5yzmoeqxj4gavm31 So, it's now just a question of how to show this. I might try to copy/pasta over the presentation logic of Docker itself. But that wouldn't help with https://git.coopcloud.tech/toolshed/abra/issues/473. I might try some fancy layout 🤔 Tips welcome!

👀 2

decentral1se added bugrelease and removed question labels 2025-01-11 11:03:22 +00:00

decentral1se added this to the abra v0.10.0 project 2025-01-11 11:03:25 +00:00

decentral1se changed title from `abra app upgrade` deploys the old version to failed update silently rolls back 2025-01-11 11:03:59 +00:00

decentral1se changed title from failed update silently rolls back to Failed update silently rolls back 2025-01-11 11:08:41 +00:00

decentral1se referenced this issue 2025-01-11 11:09:37 +00:00

If a deploy fails, log output to file for inspection #473

decentral1se added release-candidate and removed release labels 2025-01-11 12:58:36 +00:00

decentral1se commented 2025-01-12 22:53:36 +00:00

Owner

Copy Link

Copy Source

Oh woah, yeh, the output has several issues with it, also the implementation! I don't think we can just bring in the output as-is, it will be confusing (also it includes a bunch of Docker jargon in it 😬 maybe that is why I naively silenced it ages ago, I can't remember 🤔)

https://github.com/docker/cli/issues/4907

(Just posting my notes as I go...)

Oh woah, yeh, the output has several issues with it, also the implementation! I don't think we can just bring in the output as-is, it will be confusing (also it includes a bunch of Docker jargon in it 😬 maybe that is why I naively silenced it ages ago, I can't remember 🤔) https://github.com/docker/cli/issues/4907 (Just posting my notes as I go...)

decentral1se referenced this issue 2025-01-13 09:13:08 +00:00

If a deploy fails, log output to file for inspection #473

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-01-13 09:35:06 +00:00

wip: fix: expose deploy progress

decentral1se referenced this issue 2025-01-13 09:37:08 +00:00

wip: fix: expose deploy progress #484

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-01-14 11:20:22 +00:00

wip: fix: deploy status

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-01-14 12:07:20 +00:00

wip: fix: deploy status

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-01-14 14:14:43 +00:00

wip: fix: deploy status

3wordchant commented 2025-01-15 17:31:29 +00:00

Author

Owner

Copy Link

Copy Source

Ah so sorry @decentral1se , I missed all these incredible updates because of The (latest) Great SMTP Breakage. Very stoked about your idea, let me know if you want help testing.

Ah so sorry @decentral1se , I missed all these incredible updates because of The (latest) Great SMTP Breakage. Very stoked about your idea, let me know if you want help testing.

🎉 1

decentral1se added the design label 2025-01-16 07:46:46 +00:00

decentral1se added the critical fix label 2025-01-16 08:01:58 +00:00

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-01-18 09:02:13 +00:00

wip: fix: deploy status

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-01-18 12:11:48 +00:00

wip: fix: deploy status

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-02-11 10:03:10 +00:00

wip: fix: deploy status

decentral1se commented 2025-03-13 22:06:53 +00:00

Owner

Copy Link

Copy Source

I kind of got sucked into a whirpool of changes and lost my way in #484. I need to regroup and come up with a plan with a reduced feature set. One part re: the logs is broken out into #473 now. That can be implemented after we correctly record if the deployment succeed / failed / was rolled back.

I kind of got sucked into a whirpool of changes and lost my way in https://git.coopcloud.tech/toolshed/abra/pulls/484. I need to regroup and come up with a plan with a reduced feature set. One part re: the logs is broken out into https://git.coopcloud.tech/toolshed/abra/issues/473 now. That can be implemented after we correctly record if the deployment succeed / failed / was rolled back.

decentral1se self-assigned this 2025-03-16 11:48:04 +00:00

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-03-22 12:26:53 +00:00

feat: improved deploy progress reporting

decentral1se referenced this issue 2025-03-22 12:28:32 +00:00

feat: improved deploy progress reporting #524

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-03-23 07:57:45 +00:00

feat: improved deploy progress reporting

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-03-23 09:07:43 +00:00

feat: improved deploy progress reporting

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-03-23 09:13:20 +00:00

feat: improved deploy progress reporting

decentral1se referenced this issue from a commit 2025-03-23 09:13:37 +00:00

feat: improved deploy progress reporting

decentral1se closed this issue 2025-03-23 09:13:53 +00:00

decentral1se moved this to Done in abra v0.10.0 on 2025-04-14 22:00:59 +00:00

decentral1se moved this to Done in abra v0.10.0 on 2025-04-14 22:01:01 +00:00

decentral1se moved this to Done in abra v0.10.0 on 2025-04-16 05:16:08 +00:00

decentral1se moved this to Done in abra v0.10.0 on 2025-04-16 05:16:10 +00:00

decentral1se moved this to Done in abra v0.10.0 on 2025-04-19 07:28:29 +00:00

decentral1se moved this to Done in abra v0.10.0 on 2025-04-21 17:48:15 +00:00

Sign in to join this conversation.

No Branch/Tag Specified

Branches Tags

main

renovate/golang-1.26

renovate/github.com-charmbracelet-lipgloss-2.x

renovate/tonistiigi-xx-1.x

renovate/github.com-charmbracelet-log-2.x

renovate/github.com-charmbracelet-bubbletea-2.x

chore-deps

fix/492

fix/deps

fix/613

0.13.0-beta

0.13.0-rc2-beta

0.13.0-rc1-beta

0.12.0-beta

0.11.0-beta

0.10.1-beta

0.10.0-beta

0.10.0-rc2-beta

0.10.0-rc1-beta

0.9.0-beta

0.8.1-beta

0.8.0-beta

0.8.0-rc2-beta

0.8.0-rc1-beta

0.7.0-beta

0.7.0-rc3-beta

0.7.0-rc2-beta

0.6.0-beta

0.5.1-beta

0.5.0-alpha

0.4.1-alpha

0.4.0-alpha

0.4.0-alpha-rc8

0.4.0-alpha-rc7

0.4.0-alpha-rc6

0.4.0-alpha-rc5

0.4.0-alpha-rc4

0.4.0-alpha-rc3

0.4.0-alpha-rc2

0.4.0-alpha-rc1

0.3.1-alpha-rc2

0.3.1-alpha-rc1

0.3.1-rc1

0.3.0-alpha

0.2.2-alpha

0.2.1-alpha

0.2.0-alpha

0.1.8-alpha

0.1.7-alpha

0.1.6-alpha

0.1.5-alpha

0.1.4-alpha

0.1.3-alpha

0.1.2-alpha

0.1.1-alpha

0.1.0-alpha

10.0.5

10.0.3

10.0.2

10.0.1

10.0.0

9.0.0

8.0.1

8.0.0

0.7.4

0.7.3

0.7.2

0.7.1

0.7.0

checkout

0.6.0

0.5.0

0.4.1

0.4.0

0.3.1

0.3.0

0.2.0

0.1.2

0.1.1

0.1.0

Labels

Clear labels

bug

Something is not working

build

go build related issues

ci/cd

Building things with CI/CD

critical fix

https://docs.coopcloud.tech/federation/resolutions/passed/010/

design

UI/UX

documentation

Documenting all the things

duplicate

This issue or pull request already exists

easy-first-issue

Something for new people to get stuck into. We hope it's easy!

enhancement

New feature

help wanted

Need some help

i10n

Everything to do with localisation

i18n

Everything to do with internationalisation

installer

Everything to do with the install script.

invalid

Something is wrong

question

More information is needed

release

Release management

release-candidate

Related to the new release candidate

security

Security related

tech-debt

test

Unit/integration testing

wontfix

This won't be fixed

No Label bug critical fix design release-candidate

Milestone

No items

No Milestone

Projects

Clear projects

No project abra v0.10.0

Assignees

Clear assignees

3wordchant aadil (Aadil Ayub) abra-bot (Abra Bot) ammaratef45 amras (Sarma) Apfelwurm BornDeleuze Brooke carla cas (Cassowary) coopcloud cyrnel decentral1se (decentral1se) dede fauno (fauno) iexos jade (Jade Ambrose) jjsfunhouse jmakdah2 joe-irving kawaiipunk (KawaiiPunk) knoflook kolaente lambdabundesverband linnealovespie moosemower moritz notplants oxaliq (sorrel) p4u1 pharaohgraphy (Andrew 🐦‍🔥❤️‍🔥✴️) renovate-bot (Comrade Renovate Bot) ripclap simon sixsmith (Sixsmith) stevensting trav val (val (he/him)) yksflip

No Assignees decentral1se

2 Participants

Notifications

Subscribe

Due Date

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: toolshed/abra#478